Book Cover
Title Here There Be Gerblins
Author Clint McElroy, Griffin McElroy, Justin McElroy, Travis McElroy
Illustrator Carey Pietsch
Publisher First Second - 2018
First Printing First Second - 2018
Book Cover
Title Murder on the Rockport Limited!
Author Clint McElroy, Griffin McElroy, Justin McElroy, Travis McElroy
Illustrator Carey Pietsch
Publisher First Second - 2019
First Printing First Second - 2019
Book Cover
Title Petals to the Metal
Author Clint McElroy, Griffin McElroy, Justin McElroy, Travis McElroy
Illustrator Carey Pietsch
Publisher First Second - 2020
First Printing First Second - 2020
Book Cover
Title The Crystal Kingdom
Author Clint McElroy, Griffin McElroy, Justin McElroy, Travis McElroy
Illustrator Carey Pietsch
Publisher First Second - 2021
First Printing First Second - 2021
Book Cover
Title The Eleventh Hour
Author Clint McElroy, Griffin McElroy, Justin McElroy, Travis McElroy
Illustrator Carey Pietsch
Publisher First Second - 2023
First Printing First Second - 2023
Book Cover
Title The Suffering Game
Author Clint McElroy, Griffin McElroy, Justin McElroy, Travis McElroy
Illustrator Carey Pietsch
Publisher First Second - 2024
First Printing First Second - 2024
Category Graphic Novels
Warnings None
Main Characters Taako, Merle, Magnus
Main Elements Elves, Dwarves, Warriors, and pretty much everything else too
Website ---




Click to read the summaryHere There Be Gerblins

Click to read the summaryMurder on the Rockport Limited!

Click to read the summaryPetals to the Metal

Click to read the summaryThe Crystal Kingdom

Click to read the summaryThe Eleventh Hour

Click to read the summaryThe Suffering Game




This year I read a fair amount of Dungeons and Dragons, and I also read a fair amount of graphic novels. This combines the two and puts a silly twist on it by having the most inept and self-centered characters. I thought I would love it, but in the end, not so much.

I didn't mind the swearing at first, but then it just got gratuitous and non-stop, which made it less fun and more crass. And while I laughed at their misadventures and hopeless heroes and inept villains, it again, was a little too crude and rude for me. I don't watch things like Saturday Night Live because I think the humour is dumb, and this is along those lines. I didn't hate it, but it wasn't entirely to my tastes either.

I did learn a bit about how to play D&D and what a Dungeon Master's role is so that was a plus, not having ever played the game myself. And the artwork was good, it matched the style of the storytelling. And the little insets with the DM were super cute.

If I had to buy the books, I'd go Critical Role all the way. But that said, I'm curious to dig up The Adventure Zone podcasts, I wonder if it might actually be more fun listening to the dialog then reading it? And when the weather warms up a bit and I can walk to the library again, I'll be borrowing the rest of the series, after all, it is silly fun.

Aaannd...I spent quite a bit of time trying to figure out if Taako is a guy or not, they never referred to him as he or she, though at one point the group is referred to as "dudes". A little Google came up with this, which sounded about right to me! I love the "may or may not be" bit...

Taako is a "gay dude." This is "100% canonical," according to Justin. He may or may not be a man, but uses he/him pronouns.

April 2024

Petals to the Metal is no less crazy and wacky than the previous two. I think I liked this one the least of the three I've read so far, maybe because Mad Max car racing is not my thing, but its still fun to see the three goofballs messing up all along the way yet somehow always achieving their missions. Since the library is kind of enough to supply me with the rest, I'll keep on going!

June 2024

You know I think The Crystal Kingdom might have been my favorite one. Lots of pink, not that I'm a huge fan of pink but it made for spectacular illustrations. The story was interesting (I'm not big on Mad Max type races which the previous book was), and the introduction of the reaper makes me hope we'll see more of him.

September 2024

The series is really growing on me, The Eleventh Hour might be my new favorite now. I loved the time loop (and seeing the team bite the dust about a hundred different ways, but hey, its a time loop, you just start over again). And you get to learn more about the pasts of the characters when they are being tempted to use the power to fix the mistakes. And at the end of the book there's a huge reveal which made me want to rush out and get the next one...but I'll have to wait till someone returns their copy to the library first.

But I must admit The Suffering Game was...dark. While the multiples deaths in the previous one was funny, here characters had to give up limbs or otherwise be tortured to retrieve one of the artifacts they've been collection. Also there are huge reveals in this one, that there is so much more to this silly series than appeared on the surface. I have to wonder if that were there from the start or something that got built up as it went along, but it was blowing my mind. And now...I have to wait till next year for the grand finale! Looking forward to the billion questions that came up in this book get resolved.




Posted: December 2023

HOME BACK EMAIL

Background, images and content (unless otherwise noted) are © SunBlind
Do not use without permission.