Book Cover
Title The Thief
Author Jessica Brody & Joanne Rendell
Cover Art ---
Publisher HarperTorch - 2002
First Printing William Morrow - 2001
Book Cover
Title Sky Without Stars
Author Jessica Brody & Joanne Rendell
Cover Art ---
Publisher Simon Pulse - 2019
First Printing Simon Pulse - 2019
Book Cover
Title Between Burning Worlds
Author Jessica Brody & Joanne Rendell
Cover Art Heather Palisi
Publisher Simon Pulse - 2020
First Printing Simon Pulse - 2020
Book Cover
Title Suns Will Rise
Author Jessica Brody & Joanne Rendell
Cover Art Heather Palisi
Publisher Simon Pulse - 2021
First Printing Simon Pulse - 2021
Category Retelling
Warnings None
Main Characters Chatine, Marcellus, Alouette, Cerise, Roche, Etienne
Main Elements Dystopia
Website jessicabrody.com




Click to read the summaryThe Thief

Click to read the summarySky Without Stars

Click to read the summaryBetween Burning Worlds

Click to read the summarySuns will Rise




I first read the short story for free on rivetedlit.com (it's still there) and decided that given a chance, I'd like to read more. Then a few months later I also got to read the first book on that site (it was only available for one month but could pop up again). My library had just made available the second but I'll have to wait for the third and final one to be published later this year.

First, Earth has been destroyed in some way and the human race has gone to space to colonize a solar system of twelve planets. Each country has picked a planet for themselves, some of course more desirable than others, but France ended up on Laterre (*cough* "The Earth", how creative...) a planet perpetually shrouded in clouds and rain. Over the centuries a society grew up, the rich living in a domed city under a fake sky and suns, while the rest, the workers that provide what the rich need, made do with the leftover pieces of the ship that brought them there. If that sounds a little like the setup one has in Revolutionary France you wouldn't be wrong, see this is a retelling of Victor Hugo's Les Miserables.

Of course, this is the future, so we've got more advanced technology, the masses are controlled by Skins, a device implanted into their arms are birth, a kind of cell phone that's part of your body through which you get annoucements, can track your bank account and whatnot. Our "Javert" equivalent is a cyborg, droids are used to patrol the streets, and the prisoners are sent to a moon called the Bastille to mine a rare element. And if you want to go visit Germany, you need to hop on a spaceship.

The characters are the same, and yet different. Instead of the story centering on the "Valjean vs Javert" storyline, the story shifts to the other characters and the revolution itself. Now I read Les Miserables about 25 years ago so I'm not going to even try to match up plotlines and places (though clearly there are major differences with "Valjean" showing up for a dozen pages at most, "Javert" gets a bit more page-time), but the underlying core of the story is definitely there.

The one thing I couldn't quite puzzle out is why are there French words mixed in with the English text...ok I know this is France here, but then wouldn't ALL their words be in French, so tossing in random words in French wouldn't make any sense. It'd be like I'm reading an English book and havings words like "car" or "house" emphasized for no particular reason. I know it sounds cool to those who don't speak French, but it's kind of dorky to those that do. But maybe I got a hint, when they fly to another planet that is the equivalent of England, and both sides have no trouble talking to each other, that I decided that maybe there is a standard "System Divine" language used across all the planets, but each one would develop their own slang based off the original language of the settlers...I decided to go with that as an explanation.

But aside from that language quirk, I found myself really enjoying this. The worldbuilding, the characters (Marcellus is maybe a little too clueless given his upbringing but then maybe he's younger than I'm picturing him too), the tech, the slang (and I don't mean the random French words but the ones specific to this alien planet, like how the poor call the droids "bashers" because they bash around trying to catch you). Even though the books are long (over 600 pages) I didn't get bored.

November 2021

Turns out it wasn't too long a wait for the library to have the last book ready for me, in fact I wasn't ready for it and had to put it aside for a little while. It's been about 25 years since I read the original book, so I could be completely wrong, but I felt that the story started to diverge quite a bit from the original, but that's ok. In fact if the only thing that changed was the setting and the names, then there wouldn't be a point in writing the book in the first place. First of all, you'd know exactly how it ended, here you get a little suspense. Secondly, we ourselves are living in a different time and place from Victor Hugo so there are different things to say and points to make (he couldn't envision using technology to control the masses for example), though there are also many things that haven't changed at all unfortunately.

In the end, that short story teaser I started with was right, I would enjoy reading this series and I find little to complain about. I don't feel terrible that I have to give the book back to the library, which means I didn't completely adore it, but I also felt the near 700 pages I had to invest in each of the books was worth the time spent as well (I could easily read 100 pages a day). The characters grew on me, and the world spread out amongst multiple planets was an interesting one. Wonder if there were any other classic novels that were taking place in a different country during the same time period as the French Revolution, and could those tales be retold on their respective planet? I'd love to know more of the other worlds, we just barely touched on Albion (England) for example, it just opens so many possibilities.




Posted: July 2021

HOME BACK EMAIL

Background, images and content (unless otherwise noted) are © SunBlind
Do not use without permission.