Book Cover
Title The Complete Robot
Author Isaac Asimov
Cover Art ---
Publisher HarperCollins - 1995
First Printing 1982
Book Cover
Title Robot Visions
Author Isaac Asimov
Illustrator Ralph McQuarrie
Publisher Roc - 1991
First Printing 1990
Book Cover
Title Robot Dreams
Author Isaac Asimov
Cover Art Ralph McQuarrie
Publisher Ace - 1990
First Printing Berkley - 1986
Book Cover
Title The Caves of Steel
Author Isaac Asimov
Cover Art Stephen Youll
Publisher Bantam Spectra - 1991
First Printing Doubleday - 1954
Book Cover
Title The Naked Sun
Author Isaac Asimov
Cover Art Stephen Youll
Publisher Bantam Spectra - 1991
First Printing Doubleday - 1965
Book Cover
Title The Robots of Dawn
Author Isaac Asimov
Cover Art ---
Publisher Bantam Spectra - 1994
First Printing Doubleday - 1983
Book Cover
Title Robots and Empire
Author Isaac Asimov
Cover Art Michael Whelan
Publisher Ballantine - 1986
First Printing Nightfall - 1985
Book Cover
Title The Positronic Man
Author Isaac Asimov & Robert Silverberg
Cover Art Stephen Youll
Publisher Ballantine - 1986
First Printing Bantam - 1995
Book Cover
Title Gold
Author Isaac Asimov
Cover Art ---
Publisher HarperPrism - 1995
First Printing HarperPrism - 1996
Book Cover
Title "Mother Earth"
Author Isaac Asimov
Cover Art ---
Publisher Panther / Granada - 1974
First Printing Astounding Science Fiction - 1949
Category Science Fiction
Warnings None
Main Characters Susan Calvin, Powell, Donovan, Elijah Baley, R. Daneel Olivaw, Giskard, Andrew Martin
Main Elements Robots
Website ---




Getting the full set of stories but without buying duplicates is a major challenge, in fact, the most famous collection in the series "I, Robot" should be skipped as all the stories contained therein are included in other collections! I believe I have determined the minimum set of books needed to read all the stories so feel free to use the list above, or, I'm creating a table here, in publishing order, of which story appeared in which book so you can hunt them down individually.

The suggestion is - The Complete Robot, borrow Robot Visions from the library since it only adds 3 more stories, and then Robot Dreams.

Title (date)Found in
"Robbie" (1940)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"Reason" (1941)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
Liar!" (1941)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"Runaround" (1942)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"Robot AL-76 Goes Astray" (1942)The Complete Robot
"Victory Unintentional" (1942)The Complete Robot
"Catch That Rabbit" (1944)The Complete Robot
"Escape!" (1945)The Complete Robot
"Evidence" (1946)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"Little Lost Robot" (1947)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
Robot Dreams
"Mother Earth" (1949)Early Asimov Vol. 3
"The Evitable Conflict" (1950)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"Satisfaction Guaranteed" (1951)The Complete Robot
"Breeds There a Man...?" (1951)Robot Dreams
"Hostess" (1951)Robot Dreams
"The Martian Way" (1952)Robot Dreams
"Sally" (1953)The Complete Robot
"Risk" (1955)The Complete Robot
"Franchise" (1955)Robot Dreams
"Someday" (1956)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"First Law" (1956)The Complete Robot
"Jokester" (1956)Robot Dreams
"The Last Question" (1956)Robot Dreams
"Galley Slave" (1957)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"Let's Get Together" (1957)The Complete Robot
"Strikebreaker" (1957)Robot Dreams
"Does a Bee Care?" (1957)Robot Dreams
"Lenny" (1958)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"The Feeling of Power" (1958)Robot Dreams
"Spell My Name with an S" (1958)Robot Dreams
"The Ugly Little Boy" (1958)Robot Dreams
"The Machine that Won the War" (1961)Robot Dreams
"Eyes Do More Than See" (1965)Robot Dreams
"Segregationist" (1967)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"The Billiard Ball" (1967)Robot Dreams
"Feminine Intuition" (1969)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"Mirror Image" (1972)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"Stranger in Paradise" (1973)The Complete Robot
"Light Verse" (1973)The Complete Robot
Robot Dreams
"The Billiard Ball" (1967)Robot Dreams
". . . That Thou Art Mindful of Him" (1974)The Complete Robot
"A Boy's Best Friend" (1975)The Complete Robot
"Point of View" (1975)The Complete Robot
"The Tercentenary Incident" (1976)The Complete Robot
"The Bicentennial Man" (1976)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"Think!" (1977)The Complete Robot
Robot Visions
"True Love" (1977)The Complete Robot
"The Last Answer" (1980)Robot Dreams
"Lest We Remember" (1982)Robot Dreams
"Robot Dreams" (1986)Robot Dreams
"Christmas Without Rodney" (1988)Robot Visions
"Too Bad!" (1989)Robot Visions
"Robot Visions" (1990)Robot Visions
Cal (1991)Gold
Kid Brother (1990)Gold

Essays (date)

Found in

"Robots I Have Known" (1954)Robot Visions
"The New Teachers" (1976)Robot Visions
"Whatever You Wish" (1977)Robot Visions
"The Friends We Make" (1977)Robot Visions
"Our Intelligent Tools" (1977)Robot Visions
"The Machine and the Robot" (1978)Robot Visions
"The Laws of Robotics" (1979)Robot Visions
"The New Profession" (1979)Robot Visions
"The Robot As Enemy?" (1979)Robot Visions
"Intelligences Together" (1979)Robot Visions
"My Robots" (1987)Robot Visions
"The Laws of Humanics" (1987)Robot Visions
"Cybernetic Organism" (1987)Robot Visions
"The Sense of Humor" (1988)Robot Visions
"Robots in Combination" (1988)Robot Visions
"Future Fantastic" (1989)Robot Visions
"The Longest Voyage" (1983)Gold
"Inventing the Universe" (1990)Gold
"Flying Saucers and Science Fiction" (1982)Gold
"Invasion" (1990)Gold
"The Science Fiction Blowgun" (1978)Gold
"Invasion" (1990)Gold
"Golden Age Ahead" (1979) (1983)Gold
"The All-Human Galaxy" (1983)Gold
"Psychohistory" (1988)Gold
"Science Fiction Series" (1986)Gold
"Survivors" (1987)Gold
"Nowhere!" (1983)Gold
"Outsiders, Insiders" (1986)Gold
"Science Fiction Anthologies" (1981)Gold
"The Influence of Science Fiction" (1981)Gold
"Women and Science Fiction" (1983)Gold
"Religion and Science Fiction" (1984)Gold
"Time-Travel" (1984)Gold

Click to read the summaryThe Complete Robot

Click to read the summaryRobot Visions

Click to read the summaryRobot Dreams

Click to read the summaryThe Caves of Steel

Click to read the summaryThe Naked Sun

Click to read the summaryThe Robots of Dawn

Click to read the summaryRobots and Empire

Click to read the summaryThe Positronic Man

Click to read the summaryGold




The Complete Robot - this book contained a lot of stories, but one thing I found in common was that more often than not a robot would go wrong and someone would have to figure out why. I loved this, I'm a software developer and this is what I do everyday (with code, not positronic brains), and sometimes a debugger won't help, you just have to reason it out. I also loved the fact that though Asimov had his three rules of robotics, they weren't perfect, and you could see through these various stories how they could go wrong. For example in one case where a robot must obey a human command which just happened to be "Get lost!". There was also a fair amount of humour in these tales, but each and everyone of them was insightful, not just to robots and AI, but of the human condition as well. I also appreciated that he put a woman in a prominent position in the robotics company...though I was disappointed she was a psychologist rather than an engineer, and basically had to be "more robot like than the robots" to be allowed into these otherwise male oriented storylines. In fact only one robot was referred to as she (technically the others weren't male but were always called Tony or Robbie or Andrew), and that was because she didn't run on logic but instead on intuition. But I'll sigh and admit that many of these were written in the 40's and 50's and with men as the target audience. That also said, it was amusing when Asmiov put set a story in the "future", which turns out to be 1998. So I could compare what he predicted (a robot that could take care of a child) with what actually happened (24 years later, still not there yet). Though, that robot couldn't speak, the speaking robot took up an entire room...we have Alexa, Siri, etc so we came out on top there!

By far the best tale was The Bicentenial Man, later expanded into the novel The Positronic Man (as well as made into a movie with Brian Williams) which I'll review shortly...

Robot Visions - I've never read a 500 page book so fast! Well, that's because aside from three stories, everything was already included in The Complete Robot. What it did have was a little less than 100 pages of articles Asimov wrote. I was expecting longer, more in depth articles, but these must be things he wrote for Science Fiction magazines, where he either discussed robots in science fiction, or speculated what the future would be like, they weren't scientific though they were non-fiction. I have to admit a few made me almost laugh, after all he was trying to predict something and enough time has passed that a lot of what he predicted came true, only he sometimes didn't go far enough. In one article discussing the how we would have devices in our house to allow up to continue our education without the need of teachers in a classroom, he felt the device "could be no bigger than a TV, that's about the right size" and here I'm smirking since we've got cell phones that can do that for us. But he neatly described the internet, being able to access libraries and other sources of information from our home, online courses. He only missed two things, one is that a teacher may still be involved in a live class but with a webconf you can teach a thousand people at the same time. The other was the bit where people would upload more information...but he missed how people are really good at uploading junk too. His beautiful image of learning in the future marred by misinformation, and just an overwhelming mass of garbage to plow through to find the useful stuff.

Robot Dreams - I had to give up trying to find Robot Dreams in a used bookstore, but I found after reading two other books of stories, that I owned enough of them anyway. So the library it was, and while there were a few duplicates, most were new to me, but then that could also be partly because many of the stories didn't have any kind of robot/computer in them at all! Doesn't mean I didn't like those stories too, but it was a bit surprising, guess there just weren't enough stories to avoid the repeats and the non-robot fillers. I think the one I liked the best as The Last Question, spanning millenia and constantly building on itself and yet never being enough until...well I won't give it away but it was a very interestig theory about the origins of the universe, I mean why not? We still don't have better answers to those questions.

Gold - There are fifteen stories in this anthology though only two are robot related. Cal is about a robot who is an aspiring writer and in Kid Brother, a woman must choose between saving her delinquent son or the perfectly behaved robot kid brother. Of the rest of the stories, many were very short, just a couple pages long, usually with a funny twist ending. The title story Gold was particularly fun, but I highly recommend reading The Gods Themselves first (which I recommend regardless, it has one of the most alien aliens in it), it will make a lot more sense then.

"Mother Earth" - I hit the end of the year so didn't have time to read the whole Early Asimov Vol 3 collection so I just borrowed it from OpenLibrary to read this last Robot story...after all I can't have read everything but one! And this one is quite relevant to the Robot and later Empire/Foundation stories, we have the Outer World colonies being established and Earth being rejected as barbaric and germ infested in comparison. You can see Asimov's earliest thoughts on where his novels eventually went.

Now onto the novels.

The Caves of Steel - I was surprised, I didn't much like it, even though it is a famous classic and often appears on the top 100 best SF novels. I mean I liked the idea of using a detective on a future Earth, living in an enclosed city since it was believed it was too dangerous to walk around outside. And then including robots, people still afraid of them taking over their jobs or of them becoming dangerous, but at the same time needing them to do any work that needs to be done under the open sky. But somehow I just didn't like this worldbuilding, and while the mystery was engaging and I didn't guess the solution, Baley came of as, I don't know, a little clueless even though he wasn't. Some random chases, maybe too much stuff all at once. Whatever it was, I didn't see why people loved it so much except that maybe it was trailblazing the SF cop story. Also the relationship between the Baley and Olivaw, treating him at first as the machine he is, but not being able to do avoid forging a real friendship.

The Naked Sun - On the other one, this one was much more up my alley. I was fascinated by this extraterrestial world settled by humans who over time have chosen to have no physical interaction with them (kind of like our COVID times, we could hang out on Zoom but the thought of someone being in the same room as you would cause people to freak out). Here I found the worldbuilding and the mystery more engaging. There were no extraneous chase scenes (these people never leave their houses after all!). So why I liked this one and not the other I can't put my finger on. Guess the only thing to do is read the next one and see what I feel about the series as a whole!

The Robots of Dawn - well the next one confirmed it, the books grew on me. As Elijah worked through the mystery, putting the pieces together, the reader is also attempting to do the same. And while you always feel that in a regular detective novel the detective is able to make some leap of logic that is impossible for the reader to make, here we are constantly inside Elijah's head so he can't really keep stuff from us. That of course is not true of the other characters so one must determine when they are speaking the truth, or when they ard omitting something important.

Robots and Empire - Ok, I think I liked this one best, perhaps exactly because it takes place two hundred years after our main protagonist, Elijah Baley, passed away of old age. But Daneel and Giskard can go centuries more, but they haven't forgotten him and will do what they can to protect his vision. I found this one not only a good mystery but a very touching tale in general. And also perhaps a bit of a warning, as Asimov slips into most of his books, seeing how his three laws can be twisted and stretched or even just taken literally, and this will have implications in any A.I. we develop in the future. I assume with the word Empire in the title it ties into Asimov's Empire series, but as I didn't get around to reading that this year, I'll have to wait and see how that works out.

The Positronic Man - I read the Bicentenial Man short story near the start of the year, so to be honest, I had difficulty picking out what got added to extended the story into a novel. But that's ok. And it was also ok knowing the story before I started since it's a good one. A robot, with what is arguably a defect, starts to develop a personality, to develop creativity, and more significantly, to develop wants. And one of the things Andrew wants is to be acknowledged as being human. A very touching tale since honestly, if humans were more like this robot we'd all be happier people, it's almost an insult to apply the term human to Andrew. But just like Data in Star Trek, it challenges us humans to define what it means to be human. At first glance its obvious, a human is an organic being and a robot isn't. But as humans start replacing body parts with mechanical ones, and robots start replacing body parts with organic ones, it becomes rather more difficult to draw the line. Especially when the difference between the two, one considered an independent sentient being and the other as property, one can see how a unique and intelligent machine might want to be considered as something more than a factory product. You may need a kleenex box for this one. BTW, I must say the writing style of this one, one appropriate given it is about the point of view of Andrew, an "innocent" of sorts, was perfect. I can't quite put into words exactly what this style was but it was the one this story needed. And I love the touches where Asimov tosses in changes in fashion, since that's exactly what will happen in the future and most SF authors miss that!




Posted: January - December 2022

HOME BACK EMAIL

Background, images and content (unless otherwise noted) are © SunBlind
Do not use without permission.