Book Cover
Title House Atreides
Author Brian Herbert & Kevin J. Anderson
Cover Art Stephen Youll
Publisher Bantam Spectra - 1999
First Printing Bantam Spectra - 1999
Book Cover
Title House Harkonnen
Author Brian Herbert & Kevin J. Anderson
Cover Art Stephen Youll
Publisher Bantam Spectra - 2000
First Printing Bantam Spectra - 2000
Book Cover
Title House Corrino
Author Brian Herbert & Kevin J. Anderson
Cover Art Stephen Youll
Publisher Bantam Spectra - 2001
First Printing Bantam Spectra - 2001
Book Cover
Title House Atreides Vol I
Author Brian Herbert & Kevin J. Anderson
Illustrator Dev Pramanik
Publisher BOOM! Studios - 2021
First Printing BOOM! Studios - 2021
Book Cover
Title House Atreides Vol II
Author Brian Herbert & Kevin J. Anderson
Illustrator Dev Pramanik, Mariano Taibo, Raffaele Semeraro
Publisher BOOM! Studios - 2021
First Printing BOOM! Studios - 2021
Book Cover
Title House Atreides Vol III
Author Brian Herbert & Kevin J. Anderson
Illustrator Dev Pramanik
Publisher BOOM! Studios - 2022
First Printing BOOM! Studios - 2022
Category Graphic Novel
Warnings None
Main Characters Leto Atreides, Rhombur & Kailea Vernius, Vladimir Harkonnen, Pardot + Liet Kynes, Duncan Idaho, Gurney Halleck, Shaddam, Hassimir Fenring, Beast Rabban, Jessica, C'tair & D'mur
Main Elements Empires
Website Brian Herbert




Click to read the summaryHouse Atreides

Click to read the summaryHouse Harkonnen

Click to read the summaryHouse Corrino

Click to read the summaryHouse Atreides Vol I

Click to read the summaryHouse Atreides Vol II

Click to read the summaryHouse Atreides Vol III




I went into this trilogy ready to be unimpressed. Don't get me wrong, more Dune is not a bad thing, especially as Frank Herbert didn't finish the series, leaving us dangling at with a giant mystery at the end of Chapterhouse: Dune. But this is a prequel trilogy, did I really care what happened in the decades before Paul's birth.

Apparently I did, since I enjoyed it well enough. It doesnt have the depth of the original series, but it was still fun learning more about some of the characters. There were a few things I found that didn't quite work with the original series though.

The whole planet Ix thing. I always found Ix to be mysterious, and they seemed almost as outcast as the Bene Tleilax...but here Prince Rhombur is best friends forever with Leto. And yet fifteen years later during the events on Dune, we hear nothing about them. After Leto helped Rhombur regain his planet and his House, you'd think he'd lend a hand when the Atreides are destroyed in the first Dune book. So squeezing in this super-strong friendship but not explaining why they don't show up again later didn't work for me. Other things did, like they developed artificial melange, and no-ships, technologies that only show up much later in the Dune series (thousands of years later actually), but they were lost before the trilogy ended...so while I felt it was a little contrived to bring those aspects in, at least it's explained why they are unknown again when you hit the first Dune book.

A few other things didn't work either, like cyborg technology. I don't recall that being mentioned at all in the Dune series, maybe once, but here it was a big deal. But it just didn't seem to fit, and if it was so easy to keep what was essentially a head and spine alive in a cyborg body, why wasn't that use a LOT more to keep various people alive. The rich would totally go for it. And also it seemed silly how hard it was for the Tleilaxu to get ahold of genetic material. They only needed a few cells right? Well, all you need to do is go where the person had walked by some hours before and vaccuum up all the skin cells they dropped, they didn't need to raid a war memorial (and the response of destorying the war memorial was no protection at all). Getting someone's DNA should be the easiest things ever, even in our day you just need someone to drink from a cup and ta-da, you can clone them (if you had the advance tech the Bene Tleilax have).

Another warning, do NOT read these prequels before you read ALL of the six originals since they give away some of the big secrets, like what an axlotl tank is. But they the authors are writing for an existing fan base, I just felt it sorta ruins the suspense in later books as the characters try to solve the most guarded secret, it took millenia for the Bene Gesserit to figure it out, but half the characters in this one seem to be stumbling across it.

But, if you take this trilogy as a kind of glorified fanfic, but one written by professional authors and using notes from the original series creator, I felt it did add something to the worldbuilding. We learn why the Baron is so grossly overweight. We learn more about Fenring, Shaddam, Piter, Kynes and others who are barely even secondary characters in the original series, but here get their own point of view explored. Even Jessica and Leto get their chance at being in the spotlight.

Now the graphic novel version of House Atreides, the library had them so I thought, cool! And while they followed the novel just fine I had one HUGE issue with them...the Fremen almost never had blue-in-blue eyes. That's not just a detail one can forget people! That side effect of spice addiction is absolutely key to so many things (ok not really but it's not Dune without that, it's like drawing Hobbits the same height as Men). It's such a little thing to remember to get right and a disaster if you get it wrong. Even worse, when a non-Arrakis character is in shadow, they had more blue than the Fremen did. If you want to read a graphic novel adaptation of a Herbert work, find the one by Raul Allen and Patricia Martin that adapts the original book, the attention to detail there goes all the way to even remembering that mentats have sapho stained lips. There wasn't a single instance where the blue-in-blue eyes were done wrong in that version.

There are about 20 of these Brian Herbert/Kevin J. Anderson collaborations, I plan to work my way through all of them this year. Hopefully they will remain this entertaining but I wonder if there is actually enough material to warrant so many books. I guess I'll find out. The next trilogy takes us even further back in time, to the Butlerian Jihad and the Machine Wars. Will be a bit like reading the Silmarillion and seeing the origins of Middle Earth, only here we'll see how certain rules (such as not building a machine in the likeness of a man) can to be, and why they are so strongly held beliefs even millenia later.




Posted: May 2022

HOME BACK EMAIL

Background, images and content (unless otherwise noted) are © SunBlind
Do not use without permission.