Book Cover
Title Dragon's Kin
Author Anne & Todd McCaffrey
Cover Art Paul Youll
Publisher Del Rey - 2003
First Printing Del Rey - 2003
Book Cover
Title Dragonsblodd
Author Todd McCaffrey
Cover Art Les Edwards
Publisher Del Rey - 2005
First Printing Del Rey - 2005
Book Cover
Title Dragon's Fire
Author Anne & Todd McCaffrey
Cover Art Paul Youll
Publisher Del Rey - 2006
First Printing Del Rey - 2006
Book Cover
Title Dragon Harper
Author Anne McCaffrey & Todd McCaffrey
Cover Art Paul Youll
Publisher Del Rey - 2007
First Printing Del Rey - 2007
Book Cover
Title Dragonheart
Author Todd McCaffrey
Cover Art ---
Publisher Del Rey - 2008
First Printing Del Rey - 2008
Book Cover
Title Dragongirl
Author Todd McCaffrey
Cover Art Les Edwards
Publisher Del Rey - 2011
First Printing Del Rey - 2010
Book Cover
Title Dragon's Time
Author Anne McCaffrey & Todd McCaffrey
Cover Art Les Edwards
Publisher Del Rey - 2011
First Printing Del Rey - 2011
Book Cover
Title Anne McCaffrey & Sky Dragons
Author Todd McCaffrey
Cover Art Les Edwards
Publisher Del Rey - 2013
First Printing Del Rey - 2012
Category Science Fiction
Warnings None
Main Characters Kindan, Nuella, Masterharper Zist, Loranna/Arith, Pellar, Halla, Cristov, Fiona/Talenth, T'mar, Xhinna, Taria, Bekka
Main Elements Dragons
Website ---




Click to read the summaryDragon's Kin

Click to read the summaryDragonsblood

Click to read the summaryDragon's Fire

Click to read the summaryDragon Harper

Click to read the summaryDragonheart

Click to read the summaryDragongirl

Click to read the summaryDragon's Time

Click to read the summarySky Dragons




I decided to group these books together since they have two things in common, they were written by Anne's son Todd (sometimes on his own, sometimes as co-author with Anne) and because they take place it their own timeline, just at the start of the Third Pass (the Dragonflight trilogy takes place about 2 thousand years later in the Ninth Pass). This was an excellent idea on Anne and Todd's part, to give her son an opportunity to invent his own characters and stories with only some limitations in that Anne told us about what came before, and we know where we will end up. Here, we see how technologically advanced colonists start to lose access to their technology and start to forget their origins, and we start seeing how things will evolve into the future.

I have to admit I really had to stretch my acceptance of some of the concepts and ideas in these books. For example we know a little bit about watchwhers, after all one died tried to protect Lessa in the first book. We don't see much more of this dragon cousin, but here we find out that they weren't "mistakes" on the part of Wind Blossom, as implied by Dragonsdawn, but that they have a huge role to play in protecting Pern from Thread. After all, unless you can see in the dark, how do you fight Thread at night? It doesn't conveniently fall only during the day (as it seemed in all books up till now). So the whers' nocturnal nature was designed for them to fight Thread at night without rides. But by the Third Pass there are almost no whers left at all since Wind Blossom failed to share this secret purpose with anyone so the whers were considered at best a nuisance, at worst, something to be destroyed. And in the ninth they seemed to be all chained up, so....who is fighting Thread at night?

There's also what I think as a ridiculous connection and random time travel between the First Pass and the Third in Dragonsblood. I'm not sure that made any sense at all (why would Loranna's mental cry reach Wind Blossom of all people?? Why would dying fire lizards and dragons choose to land on her front doorstep??). Its one of those things you just have to try to ignore and focus on the rest of the story. Dragonheart also involves time travel, secret time travel that is, no one is supposed to know they are there...except by the time they are done half of Pern must know! I did enjoy the fact that we get to see Weyrling training in much more detail, and kind of cute to have a 14 year old "senior" Weyrwoman running a Weyr consisting of a bunch of injured older riders and a couple hatchings worth of Weyrlings.

The publishing sequence is a very confusing too. In the chronology, Dragon's Kin comes first, then Dragon's Fire, then Dragon Harper, then Dragonsblood and Dragonheart...but in publishing order Dragonsblood is the second with Dragonheart which takes place at the same time coming fifth, so it's a bit like you hear about things that happened in the past and then the authors went and filled in the missing bits then jumped back to go over the same time period (been there, done that with Moretta & Nerilka!). I got a bit confused about how old everyone was supposed to be at any moment in time. This is a very rare time I would recommend reading in chronological order!

The giant holes of logic aside, I couldn't detect much difference in writing style between mother and son, and this is a good thing, it keeps the series consistent, fast and pleasant to read, and overall I still ended up enjoying them and nearly crying when a dragon dies (in Dragonsblood we have a dragon plague so there's a lot of that going on).

But ugh, I don't like plague stories and this sequence more than doubles the total in the overall Pern series.

I then read the last three books...what an insane muddled mess, where do I start? Could it be that while it's been made clear that Timing is is considered dangerous and a last resort but now all the characters are bouncing around all over the place CONSTANTLY with themselves multiple times in one timeline, up to four, maybe even five times at the same time? It's like Todd ran out of plague stories to write so he decided he wanted to write time travel SF instead. This resulted in really confusing plots figuring out who what where and when, and sometimes even why, oh, and some characters can see the future to make things even more time-addled.

Then there's Fiona and her obsession of having the entire Weyr in her bed. Sure, she's not having sexual intercourse with *everyone*...just almost everyone. I know the Weyrs are very open sexually, given that they have to live with the passions of the dragons around them. But seriously, that whole foursome with T'mar unconcious, Kindan + Lorana flying T'mar's dragon during Fiona's queen's mating flight was just...really, really weird. Oh, and then that poor bronze had to fly another TWO mating flights one right after another while just so T'mar can recover from his concussion...WHAT?? Dragon sex to heal a brain injury? Well that's not kinky at all. And keep in mind Kindan and Lorana are a couple, and then T'mar hooks up with the Telgar headwoman while he's still the Weyrleader to Fiona's Weyrwoman and...then everyone gets pregnant and Fiona has twins, one for each male she "mated" with...and argh. Also remember half the female characters in these stories are like 10 years old so most are having sex at 13. I know this is a kind of feudal world but really, ALL the main characters are underage to start with. It does get a little icky when you think about it. And what's with the flood of super mature pre-teens? Do you really want a 10 year old as your midwife, even if her mother trained her well?

And by the last book the dragons are living in trees, and flying in low orbit on a regular basis. Anne supposedly worked on many of these books with her son but I can't imagine how she let her son go ahead and break EVERY SINGLE RULE about how dragons work. In fact if anything, it seemed like Todd was determined to do a first everything, first female blue rider, first visit by a dragon to the Dawn Sisters, first Weyr in a tree, first dragon plague, first case of multiple people bonding with a dragon during a mating flight, first human-to-human dragon-like telepathic contact, youngest ever headwoman, youngest ever Weyrwoman, youngest ever healer (why the obsession around young girls *cough* kinda uncomfortable coming from a male writer)...ugh. It's like he had to outdo himself in the "first" and/or "youngest" with every book he wrote.

The only positive I'm left with now having read to the very end of the Todd books is that he really maintained his mother's writing style, it still felt like Pern even if the plots were absurd. And he still maintained the overall optimism and positivity that Anne put into her original books. There's no really bad person, just misguided ones, and the enemy is a force of nature, there's no real evil here. In a time period of grimdark fantasy and depressing SF, Pern still comes as a welcome breath of hope for the future.

But honestly, because the Todd books are in their own time period and in fact not only don't add to the overall Pern lore but messes it up, you can just avoid them. Stop at The Skies of Pern and you won't be missing anything. If I hadn't bought all the books in naive hope they would be good when they first came out, I doubt even I, an obsessive series completer would have finished them. I'm a book hoarder, so it says something that I decided to give these books away. I have a complete Pern set and I'm willing to break it up because really, I shouldn't waste more time of my life re-reading these, once was enough.

And thus I tremble in fear of Gigi's newest book that came out end of this year, Dragon's Code...she's even overlapping Anne's core timeline that has already been very well covered by her mother. I can't imagine anything good will come from revisting Masterhaper Robinton and Piemur, if feels like that will be a HUGE mistake on her part not to pick another Pass or something in the future. Anyway, I'm not buying that book, maybe if the library picks it up (which I'm wondering is a sign that it hasn't while it has picked up books that came out two months later!) It has the potential to mess with the core Pern even worse than the damage Todd did in his personal Pass.




Posted: September-December 2018

HOME BACK EMAIL

Background, images and content (unless otherwise noted) are © SunBlind
Do not use without permission.