Book Cover
Title Hush, Hush
Author Becca Fitzpatrick
Cover Art James Porto
Publisher Simon & Shuster - 2009
First Printing Simon & Shuster - 2009
Book Cover
Title Crescendo
Author Becca Fitzpatrick
Cover Art James Porto
Publisher Simon & Shuster - 2010
First Printing Simon & Shuster - 2010
Book Cover
Title Silence
Author Becca Fitzpatrick
Cover Art James Porto
Publisher Simon & Shuster - 2011
First Printing Simon & Shuster - 2011
Book Cover
Title Finale
Author Becca Fitzpatrick
Cover Art James Porto
Publisher Simon & Shuster - 2012
First Printing Simon & Shuster - 2012
Book Cover
Title Dungeons of Langeais
Author Becca Fitzpatrick
Cover Art ---
Publisher Running Press Teens - 2010
First Printing Running Press Teens - 2010
Category Young Adult
Warnings None
Main Characters Nora Grey, Patch, Vee, Marcie, Scott, Chauncey
Main Elements Angels
Website ---




Click to read the summaryHush, Hush

Click to read the summaryCrescendo

Click to read the summarySilence

Click to read the summaryFinale




Oh my, where do I start. If you thought Twilight set a bad example, this one is far, far worse. I mean here we have a female protagonist whose gut is telling her this guy is dangerous. But for whatever reason, she keeps agreeing to hang out with him, and not like, you know, at the local coffee shop. Oh, no...she goes to the pool hall. She has this sense that he wants to kill her...and she is RIGHT, he actually does want to kill her (till true love kicks in and he's all over himself trying to protect her).

Fine, so he goes from potential murderer to guardian angel. But in the next book, its all about her not trusting him (to be fair, he wanted to kill her, did I mention that?). So every time he's seen with anything resembling a female of any species, she has a total flip out. She decides she'll return the favour and hang with another pretty boy who just rolled into town, even though her instincts are screaming at her that he's not good. This time he doesn't take her to a regular pool hall, he takes her to one where the patrons get into fights regularly and it's not unusual that someone ends up dead. But that's ok right, since her boyfriend is her guardian angel he will be obliged to rescue her and in the meantime she can show him how strong and brave she is and that she can take care of herself (*cough* taking care of yourself doesn't mean throwing yourself wantonly into danger to prove you can squirm your way out...and in her case she can't get out on her own and needs to be rescued, repeatedly).

Girls, if you're instincts are screaming at you that this guy is no good, walk the other way. When the bad guy falls madly in love with you and turns out to be your guardian angel? That's call fiction, and unrealistic fiction at that. Your actual soulmate won't make you worry in the back of your mind if he's murderous intentions, he won't insult you to your face, he won't drag you to dangerous places to show off how tough he is, and he won't lie to you with every second sentence he speaks, and he won't literally mess with your mind (Fallen and Nephilim can get inside your heads and change your thoughts). And if the only thing keeping your eyes on him is his sculpted abs...that's lust, not love, get over it.

Thus for two whole books I was gagging over the fact that the only motivation this twit of a girl had was to spite her boyfriend (who wasn't doing anything wrong, though admitedly wasn't in a position to explain exactly what he was doing) and/or hang out with bad boys because she was embarassed by her good girl image. Sigh. *bangs head on desk repeatedly*

In the third book she has amnesia and the first two books never happened. This is so cliched and only in rare cases do I find this is handled well (e.g. Corwin in Zelazny's Amber). So...say you were kidnapped and no one knew where you were for several months, including you. You get home from the hospital. What do you do at 2 in the morning on the very first night after escaping what must have been a horrible experience? You sneak out of the house alone and hang out in the cemetary where you were found, right? I mean you haven't even been home for more than a handful of hours you need to put a giant flashing light over your head "Kidnap me again, I'm an idiot and I never learn". The one thing I can say about this third book is that her reasons for doing stupid things improved, it was no longer to piss off her boyfriend (she doesn't remember him) but to find out what happened to her and to protect her mom from the creepy guy she started dating while she was missing.

And by the time I hit the fourth book I was thinking...am I re-reading Twilight? I won't say exactly what happened in the fourth book out our brain-cell deprived protagonist but it was essentially the EXACT SAME THING that happened in the Twilight series. I'm not saying one series copied the other but there are so many similarities...but for what it's worth, this fourth book was the best, with lots of twists and turns and an epic battle. She's (mostly) gotten to trust her boyfriend, though she still has the occasional regression where it's "don't tell me what to do"...so she goes ahead and gets addicted to a drug because she didn't like her boyfriend trying to protect her...sigh.

Hmm, but is like, EVERY FREAKING PERSON in that town related to the Nephilim in some way? What's the chance that some sleepy town in Maine would have an apocalyptic battle that will change the course of events for Nephilim, Fallen Angels and Archangels? Like, aren't there any of those beings in like, you know, Europe? Or Africa? Or Asia? There was an army collected in Maine but if they had pulled in all Nephilim and all the Fallen, then that town would have quadrupled in size, SOMEONE would have noticed. And of course our special snowflake protagonist could do things no one has ever done before too. Like not a single Nephilim or Fallen ever considered ordering animals around, really?!? So while this was the most interesting of the books, I spent about half the time with an eyebrow raised, unconvinced.

There was some interesting world building, but nothing, absolutely nothing, could make up for the stupidest heroine in the history of YA literature.

The last story I managed to find on OpenLibrary in the collection Kiss Me Deadly. For what it's worth, there wasn't any kissing in it. It shows Chauncey trying to avoid getting possessed during a Cheshvan in the 1700's and as such was kind of enjoyable read.

Now that I think about it, there weren't any redeemable characters really. The fallen were evil, and cruel to the Nephilim they bind by oaths. The nephilim in turn user their powers to take advantage of regular humans. And the few humans about were mostly annoying and stupid. Even the archangels were uncaring and cruel or outright corrupted. There wasn't anyone to actually root for! Which is why at the end, when I guess everyone nearly wiped each other out, it made for a more satisfying ending, the torture of reading this series could finally stop.




Posted: December 2021

HOME BACK EMAIL

Background, images and content (unless otherwise noted) are © SunBlind
Do not use without permission.