Book Cover
Title Paul of Dune
Author Brian Herbert & Kevin J. Anderson
Cover Art Stephen Youll
Publisher Tor - 2008
First Printing Tor - 2008
Book Cover
Title Winds of Dune
Author Brian Herbert & Kevin J. Anderson
Cover Art Steve Stone
Publisher Tor - 2009
First Printing Tor - 2009
Category Science fiction
Warnings None
Main Characters Paul, Jessica, Alia, Duncan, Gurney, Stilgar
Main Elements Empires
Website Brian Herbert




Click to read the summaryPaul of Dune

Click to read the summaryThe Winds of Dune




I've been reading a lot of Dune this year, starting with the originals in January, then starting on the ones written by the son in May, more or less reading two a month, so maybe I'm just feeling like I've read a little too much Dune? But honestly, I didn't feel that these two books needed to exist. I never wondered too much about what happened between the first and second books, nor between the second and the third. Sure there was the Jihad, which one would think would be pretty exciting, but Dune isn't about the details of the battles themselves, but the epic sweep of history. If anything it felt like the authors wanted to tie up loose ends from their Prelude of Dune that introduced a whole bunch of characters and events that don't pay off in the original series so they needed to squeeze that in. Like if Ix was the staunchest ally of House Atreides, why are Ixian portrayed in the original series as something just barely above the despicable Tleilaxu?

I think one reason I really enjoy the Middle Earth books is because, in the end, even if the information wasn't considered worth publishing by Tolkien, it was still written by him and just cleaned up a bit by the son. Also those other books span great expanses of history, while here we're squeezing in the details that took place within a few year gap between books. It'd be like if Tolkien wrote about what happened between Bilbo finding the Ring and Frodo starting his quest. But really nothing happened there, the dark forces started moving, sure, be who wants to read about the details of a build up to an epic event? One's imagination can fill that in just fine, with just a paragraph or two in the Lord of the Rings to cover that time period, fine, maybe a chapter or two of Gandalf exploring things (like in the movie), but not nearly 1000 pages in two books. We don't read about all the childhood adventures of Frodo because they are for the most part irrelevant.

In the end, my one thought was, "I didn't need to know this". It didn't add anything at all to the overall series (at least all the other books did in their own way) but here it felt like an excuse to sell more books and the authors struggling to find anything more to write. They were like, oh look, the original series had a few years gap here, we can fill that in. However those years were left out because it was the boring trudge from point A to point B where the next situation worth exploring begins.

Thus if you really enjoy the books by the son (I found some were winners, others losers), then go ahead and read them since it links up with those other books. However if you were already thinking you didn't enjoy them all that much, then these would be worth skipping. I can't really say that about any of the others, even the Butlerian Jihad trilogy which I didn't much like was necessary to understanding the two books that continue where the original series left off. But if you don't read these two, you won't feel like you missed anything.




Posted: October 2022

HOME BACK EMAIL

Background, images and content (unless otherwise noted) are © SunBlind
Do not use without permission.