Book Cover
Title Fallen
Author Laren Kate
Cover Art Fernanda Brussi Goncalves
Publisher Delacorte Press - 2009
First Printing Delacorte Press - 2009
Book Cover
Title Torment
Author Laren Kate
Cover Art Fernanda Brussi Goncalves
Publisher Delacorte Press - 2010
First Printing Delacorte Press - 2010
Book Cover
Title Passion
Author Laren Kate
Cover Art Fernanda Brussi Goncalves
Publisher Delacorte Press - 2011
First Printing Delacorte Press - 2011
Book Cover
Title Fallen in Love
Author Laren Kate
Cover Art Fernanda Brussi Goncalves
Publisher Delacorte Press - 2012
First Printing Delacorte Press - 2012
Book Cover
Title Rapture
Author Laren Kate
Cover Art Fernanda Brussi Goncalves
Publisher Ember Editions - 2016
First Printing 2012
Book Cover
Title Unforgiven
Author Laren Kate
Cover Art Carrie Schechter
Publisher Tinderbox Books - 2015
First Printing Delacorte Press - 2015
Category Young Adult
Warnings None
Main Characters Lucinda Price, Daniel, Cam, Arriane, Pennyweather, Roland, Gabbe, Molly, Shelby, Miles
Main Elements Angels
Website ---




Click to read the summaryFallen

Click to read the summaryTorment

Click to read the summaryPassion

Click to read the summaryFallen in Love

Click to read the summaryRapture

Click to read the summaryUnforgiven




I picked this up when they first started coming out, before I realized that while the concept of vampires, fallen angels, etc in YA literature sounded exciting with a lot of promise for great plots, that many of those books turned out to be nothing but young girls sitting on their beds complaining to the world that they aren't good enough for the guy that loves them. Oh, and of course there would be two guys, one that's nice and good and would take care of her, the other would be wild and dark and mysterious, and she would go with the dark one. 'Cause "dangerous" and "broken & brooding" make for good mates.

Anyway, after reading a few reviews I found that this would be one of those series. No real plot or worldbuilding, no character growth, just a whole lot of young adult angst and insecurities. But I already owned all but one book in the series, and I hate getting rid of books I haven't read.

So I started in with the bar so low it was flush with the floor. But in fact, I didn't instantly hate it. I'm also not going to love it, but it had something to it that made me actually want to keep going, a mystery that needs to be solved (a short way through the third book I'm pretty sure what it will be but I could be wrong).

It took them an eternity to find one another, so melodramatic...it's only seventeen years...and even the covers, while spookily gothic, don't match the vibe of the books, at all. It was like they were done for a totally different series.

There was however quite a bit I didn't like. The first book took quite a while for anything to start happening but it ends with a bit of a bang. Luce wasn't as soppy and whimpery as I feared she would be, not that I would want to be her friend either. But then there's Daniel, he should be cool right? A fallen angel who has been in love with Lucinda lifetime after lifetime, but for some unknown twist in the curse, he can't tell her....well he can't tell her a darn thing. Which means Kate can't tell the reader either. And there is nothing more annoying than having a protagonist bumbling about and getting into trouble because she is totally clueless about what is going on. To be fair, I think I'd be as frustrated as her. "Don't leave the school" is pretty clear, but when you're friends are going on a boat trip, you might want to have some idea why you can't leave the school. Otherwise your boyfriend comes off rather controlling and random, putting down rules to do nothing other than to ensure you're a well behaved girlfriend. On the other hand Luce already knows about the angel war going on and being told it's dangerous out there should be a no-brainer, so she shouldn't wander of...you know, a dozen times. Once, maybe, especially as she almost dies. But then she does it again, and again...not the brightest bulb.

And then the third book...ok, time travel through the Announcers is kind of cool, but felt more like some weird handwaving construct to allow the time travel, kind of like in Star Trek when they pull out some technobabble out of their asses to explain some phenomenon. The Announcers didn't feel real to me. And the third book is just Luce reliving life after life after life after live...and then Daniel getting a few chapters to do the same, at each iteration maybe getting a micron closer to the answer...but just a micron. It's like a soap opera, you could stop watching for a week, jump back in, and so little forward progress would have taken place you didn't miss anything. Sure, seeing the world in all the different time periods is kind of interesting, except you see so little of the periods, Luce just goes straight to either herself or Daniel, which is of course the point of all the time travelling, but it gets repetitive.

I still have another three books to go (I believe it was intended to be a trilogy to start...I guess when you really drag things out you get your audience to buy more books, I'll probaby borrow the last one from the library), and I'll keep reading since I want to understand more about how the angel society is setup up. There are not just the Fallen on the side of God and those on the side of Lucifer, but there are blind angels that are Outcasts, and some that are called Scales, but they are all barely touched and I can't figure out how they fit into the grand scheme of things. So that is what keeps me going, not the near gag-worthy eternal love between Luce and Daniel (which of course Luce couldn't even trust, being a YA protagonist and need "proof" that he really loved her).

And Shoreline was cool, a Hogwarts for Nephilim, I could have spent more time there!

Update

Fallen in Love could have been skipped, it gave some background to some of the characters that we wouldn't otherwise have had but I felt didn't add anything to the overall storyline...and what's the chance that everyone ended up having some serious romantic event occur all at the same time?

Rapture actually wraps up the series, we find out the big secret that no one could tell Lucinda (something I figured out in the third book and suspected earlier though obviously I didn't have all the details). One thing I was disappointed by is that they really didn't get into the whole good vs evil thing, in fact the angels that sided with Lucifer explain that it isn't so clear cut, however when you meet Lucifer he's really just the evil devil the Bible makes him out to be, there were no shades of grey there, so I couldn't figure out how some of the angels sided with him and felt that they could still be good guys (which they were, but kind of didn't make sense). A lot more could have been done with that aspect, after all the Throne comes off of completely selfish and in the wrong, the angels were not allowed to love each other since that takes away from the adoration they owe their creator, so there was some justification for a revolt, that absolute good wasn't all that good either.

Now the next book must have been a "Hey, my series is popular but it's finished now, how do I still manage to write more in this world?" Well you write a book from the POV of another character, in this case Cam (kind of like the Twilight series where the first book is rewritten from the POV of the male lead...but I have higher hopes for this one since Cam has his own story to tell). I didn't feel it added much to the series, and was very predictable, but I did enjoy Lucifer making Cam age prematurely, giving him a receding hairline and a paunch. Usually YA novels don't mess with the swoonworthiness of their protagonists!




Posted: August 2021

HOME BACK EMAIL

Background, images and content (unless otherwise noted) are © SunBlind
Do not use without permission.