Book Cover
Title First Warning
Author Anne McCaffrey and
Elizabeth Ann Scarborough
Cover Art Chris McGrath
Publisher HarperCollins - 2005
First Printing HarperCollins - 2005
Book Cover
Title Second Wave
Author Anne McCaffrey and
Elizabeth Ann Scarborough
Cover Art Chris McGrath
Publisher HarperCollins - 2006
First Printing HarperCollins - 2006
Book Cover
Title Third Watch
Author Anne McCaffrey and
Elizabeth Ann Scarborough
Cover Art Chris McGrath
Publisher HarperCollins - 2007
First Printing HarperCollins - 2007
Category Science Fiction / Fantasy
Warnings None
Main Characters Khorii, Khiindi, Elviiz
Main Elements Aliens, unicorns
Website The Worlds of Anne McCaffrey




Click to read the summaryFirst Warning

Click to read the summarySecond Wave

Click to read the summaryThird Watch




So as a rule, I'm not a big fan of plague stories, even when the main characters are unicorns and thus perfectly designed to heal the sick (and thus makes for a kind of obvious choice of plotline). Now, while I felt the Pern series had a fair amount of handwaving in the SF aspects, this one required some handwaving and suspension of disbelief of another kind. I mean, let's take the premise that unicorns actually existed and an advanced alien race genetically manipulated them to be kind of humanoid. Fair enough. Let's say there's even something about then that would allow them to heal (McCaffrey doesn't even attempt something scientific here to be fair), and now send two individuals of this race to a planet that has been devastated by a plague...and somehow expect them to neutralize the plague...ON THE ENTIRE PLANET BY THEMSELVES! I mean we're talking about them walking into every room of every house, clearing the sewers, healing all the plants and animals, purifying all the waterways...you get the idea, the concept isn't even remotely feasible.

Ignoring that, well, it's a light read, the characters endearing, and given the pacifist nature of their species, the series tends towards an optimistic view of the world. Though to be completely frank, the main reason I'm reading this spinoff trilogy from the original Acorna series is twofold - there were a couple unresolved loose ends in the first series to be wrapped up here, and I'm a completionist, I just feel the urge to finish series I started.

So that must make the series sound really bad, but truth if it is was actually bad I wouldn't read it, it is just unremarkable though a valiant attempt at making unicorns an SF construct rather than a fantasy one and I give her cudos for trying to do that. It turns out Acorna isn't the only unicorn to show up in an SF series, I found at least another two (both of which, like in Acorna, have "Guardians" that rescue unicorns from old Earth to preserve them)

Now this trilogy focuses not on Acorna but on her daughter Khorii. This was great for me because I had taken so long to read the Acorna series I couldn't remember what was going on and was all confused. But this is s clean slate more or less, so I didn't have to spend my time figuring out who everyone was and what was going on. Khorii, her android companion Elviiz (yes...) and her cat Khiindi (took a while to realize that was Kitty) and going on their first offworld adventure. Of course things take a turn for the worst when the plague breaks out at exactly the same time. The first book is about them getting the plague under control.

The second book, well when I read the first little bit I thought, ok now we have a zombie apocalypse, only the didn't really turn out to be zombies, they were more like ghosts, only they weren't that either. So that kept the interest as we tried to figure out what exactly was going on.

And the third book? It frankly got absurd, a really weird solution to the plague and overall wrap up to the series. Ah well, maybe that was to be expected from a series that clearly didn't intend to take itself too seriously, perhaps directed more towards young adult readers and thus was more about exciting adventures than really making much sense. In the end, I think out of all the Acorna books I only really liked the first one. Thanks goodness for libraries!




Posted: July 2019

HOME BACK EMAIL

Background, images and content (unless otherwise noted) are © SunBlind
Do not use without permission.